Skip to content

100 Best Crush Captions About Catching Feelings for Someone New

Nothing beats the feeling of a new crush, those first exciting days when everything is hopeful. If you have a great photo of your crush, we have put together a list of all the best crush captions for Instagram for your next post. We have also included the best short crush quotes for Instagram for when someone else has said it best first.

Our Favorite Crush Captions for Instagram

When he’s not yours, but you don’t want him to date anyone else.

The truth is I’m crazy for you, everyone can see that but you…

I try not to like you, but I fall even harder.

Words can’t say how much I want you to be mine.

To be your friend was all I ever wanted; to be your lover was all I ever dreamed.

That one person you never get enough of

It’s so hard having a huge crush on someone you know you’ll never have.

I want you to want me. I want to be with you. And I want you to make me yours.

Been here all along, so why can’t you see you belong with me?

In my dream, you are mine, but in my life you are a dream.

Technically, I’m single. But my heart is taken by someone I can’t call my own.

Creating a nickname for your crush that only you and your friends know.

Pink hearts with crush captions for Instagram

Stop being afraid of what could go wrong and think of what could go right.

And you have got a smile that could light up this whole town.

The problem with love is: you can love who you want. But so can they.

I stare at you when you are not looking.

When I think about you I end up having a stupid grin on my face

One whisper of your voice, and I fade away.

You captured my heart because you sing a song that only my heart can hear

I think of you so much that I see you almost everywhere I go.

The fate of love is that it always seems too little or too much.

It’s amazing how one little conversation can change things forever.

When you are online, I stare at your name waiting for you to say ‘Hi’.

A single text from you can change my mood at any moment.

I wonder what I look like in your eyes.

I am usually not shy around people unless you are around.

Sunset with cute captions about love

If you like these, you might also want to check out our other lists of WCW Captions, Being Single Captions, Smile Captions, Flirty Captions and Short Love Quotes.

That awkward moment when your crush has asked you who your crush is.

And suddenly, all the love songs were about you.

Every girl has that one guy, she has a crush on forever.

I’m so glad you are in my life, but I want to be more than friends.

Whenever I get a text from you I break out into smiles.

Avoid someone because you have a ridiculous crush on them.

I want to tell you how I feel but I don’t want to wreck the friendship we already have.

If fear didn’t exist, I’d run up to you, kiss you and tell you that I love you.

I feel like I’m waiting for something that isn’t going to happen.

It’s not that I’m afraid of telling you how I feel about you, I’m afraid of how you will react.

Our little, stupid conversation means more to me than you think.

Your voice is music to my ears, your smile is a beauty to my eyes.

Because of you, half the time I don’t even know that I’m smiling.

I want you to know, but I don’t want to tell you.

Thanks for reminding me what butterflies feel like.

Late night thoughts, and you happened to be in them.

If I got a penny every time I thought and dreamed about you, I would be rich.

The best feeling is when you look at him and he is already staring

Two people's shoes in front of a field with short love captions

The spaces between your fingers are meant to be filled with mine.

I would love to be the person that could make you laugh and smile every day.

You have no idea how fast my heart races when I see you.

Loving you is like breathing. How can I stop?

I’m waiting for the day when you’ll tell me that you’re thinking about me all the time.

It is too much for me to handle the thought of calling you mine someday.

You stole my heart, but I’ll let you keep it.

Every time I look at you, I just don’t know what to do.

Some things have to remain a secret, but you and I don’t.

That one crush that never really goes away.

I will be yours forever, just tell me when to start.

I think about you constantly, whether it’s with my mind or my heart.

I sit and wonder if you’ll ever understand just how much of me belongs to you.

I fell in love with you. I don’t know-how. I don’t know why. I just did.

I love it when I catch you looking at me then you smile and look away

C’mon! We’d look cute together.

When I see you, I admit I start to lose my grip and all of my cool.

My head says, “Who Cares”? But then my heart whispers, “You Do, Stupid”.

I ended up liking you a lot more than I originally planned.

I want you to ruin my life!

Dear Cupid, next time hit us both

I call him my boo, he just doesn’t know it yet.

Dear diary, I saw him, and he smiled at me.

Your name is my favorite word.

I think about you a little more than I should.

One text message from you is enough to turn my sullen day into a vibrant one.

I saw you for 3 seconds and it made my day.

Keep calm and have a secret crush.

Blue hearts with funny crush captions

You are my favorite notification.

The more you hide your feelings, the more you fall for them.

Real people don’t even impress me anymore.

Sorry boys, but I already have my eyes on a guy that isn’t interested.

Keep calm and propose to your crush.

You make my dopamine levels go all silly.

Love‘s a game. Wanna play?

Don’t leave me hanging like the Mona Lisa.

I’m still trying to get over a guy I never even dated.

Smiling like an idiot.

So there’s this person…

I sorta, kinda, maybe, might, slightly, possibly like you.

So there you have it! Our list of captions. Hopefully you found the perfect one for you.

Now go share your crush photo!

Woman holding up a clear chunk of ice on the beach

About the Author

Laynni Locke

I am Laynni Locke, a Canadian writer, reader and traveller with a passion for sharing life’s moments on social media. Keeping friends and family in the loop of our lives though photos and videos has become an essential activity for most.

And it doesn’t matter if you are travelling, celebrating a special occasion or just appreciating day-to-day life, when you take that perfect photo you are going to need the perfect caption or quote before you share it. Which is why we started Routinely Shares, providing comprehensive lists of quotes and captions to cover every occasion, adventure or loved one.

With extensive experience as a travel writer, social media specialist and grant writer, I have made it my mission to curate the best and easiest to use lists for your next post.

Leave a Reply